Why Does My Partner Want to Argue About Everything?

Have you noticed that the conversations you have with your partner always seem to end in arguments, even when you discuss topics with zero stakes? Have you noticed how much they seem to enjoy arguing? Are you getting sick of it?

Sure, it can be entertaining as a mental exercise to debate silly topics every once in a while, and even significant arguments are healthy in relationships from time to time because they provide an opportunity for open communication. But having every single conversation devolve into a debate? It can get exhausting quickly.

So what can you do about your partner’s propensity to take everything you say to task? The first step is to understand why they may be starting arguments with you. From there, you can then choose how to handle these situations when they come up.

Reasons Why Your Partner Wants to Argue About Everything

1. They are unhappy.

Whether the reason has to do with you specifically or because they are dissatisfied with some other aspect of their life, they may be coping by displacing their negative feelings. The modus operandi? Picking arguments over seemingly nothing. 

In other words, they are taking out their frustrations on you. Annoying as it is, more importantly, it is unfair and warrants a longer discussion about healthy communication and the standards by which you should treat each other in a relationship.

2. They are insecure.

When some people suffer from low self-esteem, they sometimes feel the need to compensate for their lack of self-worth by putting down others. For example, if an individual is insecure about their intelligence, they may overcompensate by showing off how smart they are. 

They can do this by, you guessed it, regularly starting debates with others, questioning ideas, and attempting to prove why they are right and everyone else, including you, is wrong. 

3. That is how their parents interacted.

Our upbringing plays a crucial role in how we behave in relationships as adults. In many ways, we learn our communication skills from our parents. So when we have parents who criticize and question each other and argue over everything, we can pick up those same habits and carry them into adulthood. 

If you have been around your partner’s family and they speak in a similar fashion to your partner, then your partner may have learned those traits during childhood. So, for your partner, the argumentative behavior may just be their normal style of communication, as unwelcome as it is for you. They may not even be aware of it.

4. This is their nature.

People exist all over the spectrum of agreeableness. On one end are people pleasers who actively go out of their way to prevent conflict and arguments even to their own detriment, while on the other end are high-conflict personalities. The latter group can include stubborn people who are set in their ways with no room for alternative perspectives, as well as eristic people who actively enjoy the spirit of debate. 

Another way to say this is that some people naturally have argumentative personalities, and that is just who they are. They will start arguments simply because they enjoy arguing or because they cannot empathize with others. In any event, this is who they are. As the late Maya Angelou said, “When people show you who they are, believe them the first time.” Thereafter, you need to make some serious choices.

What to Do About Your Partner’s Need to Argue

While constant arguing can threaten a relationship, it does not have to lead to a breakup. There are specific ways to handle your partner’s love of mental sparring and your distaste for it.

1. Learn to live with it.

As discussed earlier, your partner’s argumentative spirit may simply be part of who they are and that it was part of who they were when you met and fell in love. Our partners will never be perfect, and they will always have traits that irritate us. 

So ask yourself if their love of and desire to start debates over everything is worth ending your relationship over. If you answered no, then accepting them for who they are may very well be what you have to do to keep your relationship. As the saying goes, love ‘em or leave ‘em.

2. Exit the conversation when a debate begins.

You can help your partner improve their habits with how you respond. For example, if you notice they are trying to pick a fight, you can stay composed and exit the conversation instead. In other words, make it a point not to engage. 

You can do this by picking your battles and letting them “win” the argument they started (because who cares anyway). You can do this by acknowledging their perspective or saying something along the lines of “I see what you mean” and not fighting back. Alternatively, you can tell them that you are not going to argue right now and leave the room or go for a walk. 

But whatever you do, don’t let them rile you up. Acting or, rather, reacting may make you say something you regret, causing an even larger argument to ensue.

3. Communicate how you feel about the constant debating.

However, if you determine that you can no longer put up with their constant debating and questioning of you, you need to communicate that to them. They may not realize their need to debate, and their love of it negatively impacts you. In that case, tell them how you are feeling and how their habitual arguing is affecting you.

That said, be careful not to sound accusatory or attack their character. You do not want to put your partner on the defensive. Instead, you will want to create an environment in which you can enjoy an open stream of dialogue without one of you feeling uncomfortable. So see how receptive they are to repairing your dynamic and, if necessary …  

4. Seek help from a mental health professional or relationship coach.

If you are still unable to resolve the constant bickering in your relationship or feel you need additional support, you can seek help from a mental health professional or relationship coach. Such a professional can facilitate open dialogue between you and your partner while also coming up with new communication strategies to implement in your relationship. 

Final thoughts …

Some relationships are worth saving, and others are not. But to identify which are which, you need to address issues with your partner as they arise and make critical decisions together about how you will handle them. Hopefully, you and your partner will agree that the best method to improve your communication skills is one topic worth debating.